8 Overlooked Menu Issues That Could Be
Costing You Thousands

When Block Brewing Company in Michigan asked us to run a Menu Matrix Review, they felt like something could be improved but didn’t know what. They came ot HotOperator for advice on guiding guests, supporting sales, and driving profits.

Once we dug in, we uncovered eight key issues that were quietly working against them. While they haven’t yet implemented the redesign we recommend, the findings alone revealed a clear path to stronger profitability—and each could apply to your restaurant, too.

1. Menu Highlights Were Hurting, Not Helping

The items that were supposed to draw attention were actually pulling focus away from the most profitable dishes. Good intentions, bad result. Simply put, the highlights we designed incorrectly. Something we can fix.

2. No Clear Mental Anchoring

Next is Mental Anchoring. Without strong anchoring points on the menu, guests weren’t being guided toward the right choices—especially higher-margin items. Mental anchors are subtle, but when done right, they direct guest decisions in a powerful way. Most restaurants miss this very important point.

3. Underperforming Items Were Stagnating Sales

Then we found that some dishes, like the Caesar salad, just weren’t moving. Rather than continuing to push a dish that wasn’t resonating, we recommended new, on-trend alternatives based on guest preference data. These are items we know will work form a marketing perspective.

4. Strategic Pricing Was Missing

Once the items were decided, we offered examples where Block Brewing was inadvertently underpricing several items—and overpricing others. There was no structured pricing strategy in place, which meant missed margin opportunities across the board. There are very specific price points that will affect consumer behavior, and Block Brewing was missing every one of them.

5. Fan-Favorite Items Were Nowhere to Be Found

Along with strategic pricing issues, we also realized that guests expect need to see certain items that consumers crave—like fried cheddar nuggets, hot chicken sandwiches, and more. Not offering these meant missing out on easy wins that competitors were capitalizing on. Further, while a few items did stand out, they were not necessarily items that only Block Brewing could be famous for.

6. Confusing Menu Layout

The menu was organized vertically, with vertical categories stacked next to each other. This made the menu difficult to scan and caused decision fatigue. We suggested a shift to vertical menu / horizontal item layout, which is much easier for guests to digest (literally and figuratively).

7. Small Plates Were Killing Upsells

They had a “Small Plates” section instead of a traditional “Appetizers” section. The result? Guests were treating these as entrées—cannibalizing higher-ticket items and eliminating the chance for incremental sales. It’s fine to have a small category of small plates, but is essential to have an appetizer section to capture incremental sales.

8. Desserts and Sides Were Virtually Invisible

Finally, there was no dessert section, and side dishes were buried or hard to locate. That’s a missed opportunity for add-ons and increased check averages. The main items on any menu are what pay the bills, the incremental sales all go right to the bank in added profits.

The Takeaway

Block Brewing’s menu wasn’t broken—it was simply unoptimized. The good news? These are exactly the kinds of issues we look for and fix through our $695 Menu Matrix Review.

By applying menu engineering, psychology, and award-winning layout strategies, we help restaurants uncover hidden profit opportunities—without raising food costs or overhauling their kitchen.

Want to see what your menu might be hiding?
Book your Menu Matrix Review today!

Or, if you’re not quite ready, reach out and we’ll walk you through the process.